Declan Rice Faces Fitness Dilemma as Tuchel Weighs Midfield Options

Declan Rice has been a pivotal figure for both his club, Arsenal, and the England national team, but recent performances raise concerns about his fitness. Described as a "freak of nature" by former teammate Aaron Cresswell, Rice has played 360 matches since the start of the 2020-21 season, showcasing his stamina and importance. However, during England's chaotic 4-2 win over Croatia in their World Cup opener on Wednesday, Rice appeared fatigued. His 63rd appearance of the 2025-26 season revealed tactical issues, particularly with the midfield shape, as he struggled to maintain his usual dominance against players like Luka Modric. Thomas Tuchel, England's head coach, expressed concerns after Rice was substituted in the 72nd minute, a rare move for the vice-captain, who felt discomfort in his lower back and upper hamstring. Although Rice insisted he would be fit for the upcoming match against Ghana, the potential for a worsened injury complicates England's midfield dynamics. Without Rice, England lacks a direct replacement. Options like Kobbie Mainoo and Jordan Henderson do not match Rice's physicality and skill set. Tuchel's initial tactical shift, moving Jude Bellingham back, proved ineffective, prompting a switch that saw Djed Spence come on, allowing Reece James to adapt to a midfield role. James, who has experience playing in midfield, could be crucial if Rice's minutes need management. His versatility has been acknowledged by Tuchel, who has come to appreciate James's capabilities beyond a right-back role. However, James's own fitness history, including a prolonged absence due to hamstring injuries, poses another concern for England. With the World Cup's demands escalating, Tuchel faces a pressing need to devise alternative strategies to ensure England can sustain their performance without over-relying on Rice. If England progresses to the final, Rice could approach 70 appearances this season, underscoring the urgency for Tuchel to explore other options.
Source: The Guardian Sport - 2026-06-19